The Truth About Unemployment Eligibility in California
By VICKY BROWN
Unemployment benefits are one of the most misunderstood aspects of managing people in California workplaces. If you’ve ever been shocked to learn that a former employee—who you fired—is now collecting unemployment, you’re not alone. Many small business owners and managers assume they know how the system works, but the truth about unemployment eligibility in California is more nuanced than most realize.
Understanding how the state’s Employment Development Department (EDD) evaluates claims isn’t just helpful—it’s essential. Because when it comes to unemployment, what you think you know might not protect your business.
The Big Myth: Fired = Eligible, Quit = Not
A lot of employers operate under a simple rule: if an employee is fired, they automatically qualify for unemployment; if they quit, they don’t. But that’s not how the EDD sees it.
In California, eligibility isn’t determined by how someone left their job—it’s determined by why they left. The EDD looks closely at the underlying circumstances. Did the person leave voluntarily for a compelling reason? Were they terminated for what qualifies under state law as “misconduct”?
The EDD investigates both sides of the separation. They’ll review documentation, talk to the employee, and often request a written statement from you. The outcome will hinge on what they find—not just on what you call the termination.
What Qualifies as Misconduct Under California Law?
Here’s where things get especially tricky for employers. Many assume that if someone was a poor performer or had “attitude problems,” they’re automatically disqualified from benefits. But legally, misconduct is defined very narrowly.
In California, misconduct must be:
- Willful
- Substantial
- A clear violation of known company policies or expectations
Letting someone go because they weren’t meeting performance goals or because they “weren’t a good fit” usually won’t meet that threshold. Even chronic lateness might not disqualify someone—especially if you didn’t enforce attendance policies consistently or failed to document your warnings.
But issues like theft, violence, or gross insubordination? Those are far more likely to be classified as misconduct—especially if you can prove the behavior and show that the employee was aware of the rules.
“…In California, eligibility isn’t determined by how someone left their job—it’s determined by why they left.“
Can Employees Who Quit Still Get Benefits?
Yes—if they left for what the EDD considers “good cause.”
Employees may qualify for benefits after quitting if they can demonstrate they left for serious, legitimate reasons. These might include:
- Unsafe or hazardous working conditions
- Harassment or discrimination
- Major reductions in pay or hours
- Family or medical emergencies (in some cases)
But there’s a catch: the employee has to show that they tried to resolve the issue before walking away. If they didn’t raise concerns, request accommodations, or attempt to improve the situation, their claim may be denied.
What Employers Can—and Should—Do
As an employer, you don’t get to decide whether someone qualifies for unemployment. That authority belongs solely to the EDD. But you do play a crucial role in influencing that decision.
Here’s how to protect your business while remaining fair and compliant:
Document Everything
Verbal warnings won’t cut it. Maintain written records of performance reviews, disciplinary actions, and any policy violations. Have employees sign acknowledgments when possible.
Be Consistent
Apply policies fairly across the board. If you fire one person for being late after three warnings, everyone else should be held to the same standard. Inconsistency can weaken your case if a claim is contested.
Respond to EDD Notices Promptly
Missing an EDD deadline—even by a day—can result in an automatic loss, no matter how solid your case is. Set up systems to ensure timely responses to all unemployment-related notices.
Avoid Emotional Decisions
Don’t fire someone in the heat of the moment. If you skip steps or fail to document the reason for a termination, you’re setting yourself up for a claim you probably won’t win.
Know When to Let It Go
Sometimes it’s not worth contesting a claim. If you don’t have strong documentation, or if the time and cost of fighting it outweigh the benefit, it may be better to let it go and focus on moving forward.
Stay Informed
Unemployment laws and EDD practices evolve. Stay connected with an HR professional or employment attorney to ensure you’re operating within current guidelines.
Whether you’re an entrepreneur jumping into a leadership role, a seasoned business pro with new HR responsibilities, or just starting your HR career – we’ve got the right path to guide you through your HR hurdles.
Check out the Leaders Journey Experience. This online education platform holds the LJE Masterclass, HR SimpleStart Academy and HR FuturePro Academy.
Not sure where to start – take the quiz!
Unemployment Doesn’t Equal Employer Failure
It’s important to remember: if a former employee is awarded unemployment benefits, it doesn’t mean you did something wrong. It doesn’t mean you’re a bad leader. The unemployment system is designed to support workers who lose jobs through no fault of their own—not to punish employers.
If you’ve terminated someone ethically, followed your policies, and documented your actions, you’ve done your part. Your job isn’t to prevent claims at all costs—it’s to build a work environment that minimizes risk through clear communication, consistent standards, and fair treatment.
Final Thoughts
Understanding how unemployment eligibility in California works is a key part of running a responsible business. It protects you from unnecessary liability, ensures that you’re handling separations correctly, and allows you to make smarter decisions when claims arise.
Don’t rely on myths or guesswork. Get your systems in place, document your practices, and stay informed. When claims come in—and at some point, they will—you’ll be ready. And that confidence frees you up to focus on what really matters: leading your team and growing your business.
Spread the word
MORE HUMAN, MORE RESOURCES
310.308.7680 option 1
hello@idomeneoinc.com